| 1 | 4:18.66 | James MoehringerMepham | Mepham '17 | Eastern States Invitational | 2017 |
| 2 | 4:21.17 | Owen SkeeteWestbury | Westbury '11 | Eastern States Invitational | 2011 |
| 3 | 4:21.78 | Myles MunroSeaford | Seaford '25 | Massapequa Chief Invitational - Under The Lights | 2024 |
| 4 | 4:23.98 | Thomas BurfeindNorth Shore | North Shore '21 | Stony Brook Snowflake Classic | 2024 |
| 5 | 4:24.62 | Ryan WatsonManhasset | Manhasset '18 | Eastern States Invitational | 2018 |
| 6 | 4:25.04 | Christopher TardugnoOyster Bay | Oyster Bay '24 | Stony Brook Snowflake Classic | 2026 |
| 7 | 4:25.05 | Daren ZhongFriends Academy (Li) | Friends Academy (Li) '26 | Massapequa Chiefs Invitational - Under The Lights | 2025 |
| 8 | 4:25.84 | Ian FrazerWantagh | Wantagh '26 | Massapequa Chiefs Invitational - Under The Lights | 2025 |
| 9 | 4:25.90 | Ryan CooneyMassapequa | Massapequa '13 | Massapequa Under the Lights | 2013 |
| 10 | 4:26.28 | John CyprusManhasset | Manhasset '18 | Eastern States Invitational | 2017 |
| 11 | 4:27.26 | Aidan CaggianoManhasset | Manhasset '18 | Eastern States Invitational | 2018 |
| 12 | 4:27.47 | Andrey PodskrebkinMassapequa | Massapequa '24 | Massapequa Chief Invitational - Under The Lights | 2024 |
| 13 | 4:27.55 | Aidan SweeneyManhasset | Manhasset '18 | Eastern States Invitational | 2018 |
| 14 | 4:27.86 | Owen StachlikWantagh | Wantagh '25 | Massapequa Chiefs Invitational - Under The Lights | 2025 |
| 15 | 4:29.00 | Michael GradyEast Meadow | East Meadow '15 | Massapequa Under the Lights | 2013 |
| 16 | 4:29.60 | Archie CheslerMassapequa | Massapequa '24 | Massapequa Chief Invitational - Under The Lights | 2024 |
| 17 | 4:29.65 | Christopher CourtsManhasset | Manhasset '19 | Eastern States Invitational | 2018 |
| 18 | 4:29.70 | Daniel SmithDivision Avenue | Division Avenue '26 | Massapequa Chief Invitational - Under The Lights | 2024 |
| 19 | 4:30.29 | George ThomatosFarmingdale | Farmingdale '25 | Massapequa Chiefs Invitational - Under The Lights | 2025 |
| 20 | 4:30.44 | Aiden WatsonIsland Trees | Island Trees '21 | Stony Brook Snowflake Classic | 2025 |
| 21 | 4:31.92 | Bryce ThalheimerManhasset | Manhasset '19 | Eastern States Invitational | 2018 |
| 22 | 4:33.10 | Riley FunkPaul D. Schrieber / Port Washi | Paul D. Schrieber / Port Washi | Massapequa Chiefs Invitational - Under The Lights | 2025 |
| 23 | 4:34.97 | Justin BlancheManhasset | Manhasset '17 | Eastern States Invitational | 2017 |
| 24 | 4:35.80 | Chucky SkidmoreMepham | Mepham '15 | Massapequa Under the Lights | 2013 |
| 25 | 4:36.18 | Joshua MichelKellenberg | Kellenberg '19 | Eastern States Invitational | 2017 |
| 26 | 4:36.29 | Christopher CourtManhasset | Manhasset '19 | Eastern States Invitational | 2017 |
| 27 | 4:36.92 | Michael TurnerMassapequa | Massapequa '19 | Eastern States Invitational | 2018 |
| 28 | 4:37.34 | Lukas DerasmoPaul D. Schrieber / Port Washi | Paul D. Schrieber / Port Washi | Massapequa Chiefs Invitational - Under The Lights | 2025 |
| 29 | 4:38.30 | Jesse BuaLynbrook | Lynbrook '13 | Massapequa Under the Lights | 2013 |
| 30 | 4:40.13 | Brian GuiheenChaminade | Chaminade '26 | Massapequa Chiefs Invitational - Under The Lights | 2025 |
| 31 | 4:40.76 | Ryan MelkunW. Tresper Clarke | W. Tresper Clarke '25 | Massapequa Chiefs Invitational - Under The Lights | 2025 |
| 32 | 4:41.86 | Thomas McKennaKellenberg | Kellenberg '18 | Eastern States Invitational | 2017 |
| 33 | 4:41.90 | Dietrich MoselKellenberg | Kellenberg '14 | Massapequa Under the Lights | 2013 |
| 34 | 4:42.50 | Cesar DieguezValley Stream Central | Valley Stream Central '13 | Massapequa Under the Lights | 2013 |
| 35 | 4:42.54 | Luke BenantiChaminade | Chaminade | Massapequa Chiefs Invitational - Under The Lights | 2025 |
| 36 | 4:43.17 | Daniel EganChaminade | Chaminade '26 | Massapequa Chiefs Invitational - Under The Lights | 2025 |
| 37 | 4:43.37 | Brent HarrisonChaminade | Chaminade '12 | Eastern States Invitational | 2011 |
| 38 | 4:43.40 | Michael PuleioMassapequa | Massapequa '13 | Massapequa Under the Lights | 2013 |
| 39 | 4:43.61 | Daniel HiltonChaminade | Chaminade '26 | Massapequa Chiefs Invitational - Under The Lights | 2025 |
| 40 | 4:45.18 | Daniel PetrusoManhasset | Manhasset '17 | Eastern States Invitational | 2017 |
| 41 | 4:47.83 | Dylan AmbroiseKellenberg | Kellenberg '18 | Eastern States Invitational | 2017 |
| 42 | 4:52.78 | Pablo LitumaValley Stream South | Valley Stream South '05 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 43 | 4:53.68 | Drew MillerManhasset | Manhasset '19 | Eastern States Invitational | 2018 |
| 44 | 4:54.92 | Lucas MaleyManhasset | Manhasset '21 | Eastern States Invitational | 2018 |
| 45 | 4:56.30 | Jon AmayaMepham | Mepham '06 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 46 | 4:57.56 | Adam StefanManhasset | Manhasset '19 | Eastern States Invitational | 2018 |
| 47 | 4:57.77 | Michael BergerJFK Bellmore | JFK Bellmore '06 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 48 | 5:03.84 | Matthew BergerJFK Bellmore | JFK Bellmore '06 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 49 | 5:05.47 | Mitchell KastoffHewlett | Hewlett '07 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 50 | 5:06.44 | Peter DempseyJFK Bellmore | JFK Bellmore '05 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 51 | 5:11.13 | Brandon BrownHewlett | Hewlett '05 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 52 | 5:12.49 | Kenneth KingWestbury | Westbury '06 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 53 | 5:14.94 | Kevin SheehanMepham | Mepham '07 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 54 | 5:22.95 | Matt ShermanJericho | Jericho '08 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 55 | 5:24.18 | Jeff KaufmanHewlett | Hewlett '08 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 56 | 5:24.41 | Daniel LupnMepham | Mepham '07 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 57 | 5:25.30 | Zaid HamarshaValley Stream South | Valley Stream South '07 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 58 | 5:30.51 | Alex KozinSeaford | Seaford '08 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 59 | 5:31.41 | Kyle CottoneMepham | Mepham '08 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 60 | 5:32.06 | Steven PadillaValley Stream North | Valley Stream North '07 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 61 | 5:39.94 | Harlod ColonFreeport | Freeport '07 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 62 | 5:50.92 | Mustafa TelabValley Stream North | Valley Stream North '06 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 63 | 5:51.73 | Mark FaberHewlett | Hewlett '08 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 64 | 5:56.41 | John MenendezWestbury | Westbury '06 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 65 | 5:59.07 | Michael BentoWest Hempstead | West Hempstead '07 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 66 | 6:06.07 | Anupan SadanandaClarke | Clarke '08 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 67 | 6:12.30 | Michael BukiJericho | Jericho '08 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 68 | 6:14.87 | Jared LeventhalHewlett | Hewlett '08 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 69 | 6:19.80 | David BuziashviliHewlett | Hewlett '08 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 70 | 6:22.23 | Pat BurkeMepham | Mepham '07 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 71 | 6:24.07 | Michael WongHewlett | Hewlett '08 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 72 | 6:24.80 | Nick MonetaMepham | Mepham '08 | 2005Cougar Invitational Results | |
| 73 | 6:35.93 | Michael KantrowitzOceanside | Oceanside '23 | Binghamton Banana Relays | 2025 |
| 74 | 7:13.23 | John GreenMalverne | Malverne '05 | Binghamton Banana Relays | 2025 |
