| 1 | 4:27.14 | Brian MichelsPatchogue-Medford | Patchogue-Medford '15 | St Joeph College Men | |
| 2 | 4:32.87 | Gerard ConnellySmithtown East | Smithtown East '15 | St Joeph College Men | |
| 3 | 4:33.13 | Sean KildareSt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '15 | St Joeph College Men | |
| 4 | 4:33.43 | Rory HanniganSt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '15 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2014 |
| 5 | 4:34.10 | Brian WersanSachem North | Sachem North '10 | Molloy College Indoor Invitational | 2014 |
| 6 | 4:36.78 | Matthew PayampsSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '19 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2017 |
| 7 | 4:36.89 | Christopher LangerSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '16 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2015 |
| 8 | 4:37.59 | Sean SullivanSt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '13 | St. John's University Bill Ward Invitational | 2017 |
| 9 | 4:38.47 | Bryan ReillySt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '14 | St Joseph's College Indoor Invitational | 2015 |
| 10 | 4:39.01 | Steven MosherCopiague | Copiague '15 | St Joeph College Men | |
| 11 | 4:39.22 | Frederick BuckholtzSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '16 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2015 |
| 12 | 4:39.64 | Thomas NewhamPatchogue-Medford | Patchogue-Medford '17 | St Joseph's College Indoor Invitational | 2018 |
| 13 | 4:40.04 | Brian HealySt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '20 | Saint Anthony's Developmental Meet 2 | 2019 |
| 14 | 4:40.34 | Austin McGloneWilliam Floyd | William Floyd '12 | St Joseph's College Indoor Invitational | 2015 |
| 15 | 4:40.35 | James O'BrienSt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '16 | St Joseph's College Indoor Invitational | 2018 |
| 16 | 4:41.17 | Timothy MonahanConnetquot | Connetquot '16 | St. John's University Bill Ward Invitational | 2016 |
| 17 | 4:42.33 | Anthony SearaLindenhurst | Lindenhurst '13 | St. John's University Bill Ward Invitational | 2014 |
| 18 | 4:42.85 | Patrick FiorilloSt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '20 | Saint Anthony's Developmental Meet 2 | 2019 |
| 19 | 4:43.67 | Kevin MurraySt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '12 | Molloy College Indoor Invitational | 2015 |
| 20 | 4:43.93 | Ilya WilsonIslip | Islip '16 | St. John's University Bill Ward Invitational | 2016 |
| 21 | 4:44.26 | Justin MacariSmithtown East | Smithtown East '13 | St. John's University Bill Ward Invitational | 2014 |
| 22 | 4:45.24 | John AikenWalt Whitman | Walt Whitman '12 | Molloy College Indoor Invitational | 2014 |
| 23 | 4:46.20 | Timothy FlynnSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '07 | St. John's University Indoor Track Meet | 2010 |
| 24 | 4:49.18 | John ConnollySt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '19 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2018 |
| 25 | 4:50.20 | Jonathan SolarSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '20 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2018 |
| 26 | 4:50.27 | Matthew HealySmithtown West | Smithtown West '16 | St Joseph's College Indoor Invitational | 2018 |
| 27 | 4:50.68 | Patrick HurdSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '14 | Saint Anthony's Boys Developmental Meet | 2013 |
| 28 | 4:50.99 | Brian KreiderSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '14 | Saint Anthony's Boys Developmental Meet | 2013 |
| 29 | 4:50.99 | Carey BrowneSt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '15 | St Joseph's College Indoor Invitational | 2018 |
| 30 | 4:51.14 | Joshua RomanHuntington | Huntington | St Joseph's College Indoor Invitational | 2018 |
| 31 | 4:52.96 | John O'ConnellSt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '20 | Saint Anthony's Developmental Meet 2 | 2019 |
| 32 | 4:53.30 | Tim SeebergerSt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '15 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2014 |
| 33 | 4:53.39 | Aj McKeownMiller Place | Miller Place '13 | St Joseph's College Indoor Invitational | 2015 |
| 34 | 4:54.45 | Kevin SolarSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '14 | Saint Anthony's Boys Developmental Meet | 2013 |
| 35 | 4:54.45 | Kevin MossSt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '16 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2014 |
| 36 | 4:54.54 | Shane MartensenEast Islip | East Islip '13 | St. John's University Bill Ward Invitational | 2014 |
| 37 | 4:54.83 | Patrick KutchSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '18 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2017 |
| 38 | 4:54.86 | Alex GarciaSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '15 | Saint Anthony's Boys Developmental Meet | 2013 |
| 39 | 4:56.12 | Erick RiveraCopiague | Copiague '16 | St Joseph's College Indoor Invitational | 2018 |
| 40 | 4:56.45 | Michael HerbertSmithtown West | Smithtown West '15 | St Joseph's College Indoor Invitational | 2016 |
| 41 | 4:57.04 | Brennan LopezSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '19 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2017 |
| 42 | 4:57.90 | Matthew GoidellSt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '12 | Molloy College Indoor Invitational | 2015 |
| 43 | 4:59.41 | Robert FestaNorth Babylon | North Babylon '11 | Molloy College Indoor Invitational | 2014 |
| 44 | 4:59.51 | Joshua ChungSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '20 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2018 |
| 45 | 4:59.52 | Luke ConnollySt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '21 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2018 |
| 46 | 4:59.78 | Emanuel SanchezSt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '21 | Saint Anthony's Developmental Meet 2 | 2019 |
| 47 | 4:59.90 | Aidan HarriganSt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '22 | Saint Anthony's Developmental Meet 2 | 2019 |
| 48 | 5:00.06 | Sebastian Hunter CuyjetSouthampton | Southampton '16 | Saint Anthony's Boys Developmental Meet | 2013 |
| 49 | 5:01.20 | Aidan HealySt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '18 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2014 |
| 50 | 5:03.34 | John SuchoparConnetquot | Connetquot '12 | Molloy College Indoor Invitational | 2014 |
| 51 | 5:04.24 | Liam AdipietroSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '20 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2018 |
| 52 | 5:04.25 | Matthew RedaSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '19 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2017 |
| 53 | 5:04.36 | Andrew HealySt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '21 | Saint Anthony's Developmental Meet 2 | 2019 |
| 54 | 5:04.68 | Evan McCrannLindenhurst | Lindenhurst '17 | St. John's University 14th Annual Bill Ward Invitational | 2018 |
| 55 | 5:04.90 | Owen McCarthySt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '20 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2018 |
| 56 | 5:06.79 | Chris McGrathSt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '22 | Saint Anthony's Developmental Meet 2 | 2019 |
| 57 | 5:07.02 | Ryan PaganoWalt Whitman | Walt Whitman '11 | St Joseph's College Indoor Invitational | 2018 |
| 58 | 5:08.16 | Nick DeLucaMount Sinai | Mount Sinai '16 | St. John's University Bill Ward Invitational | 2016 |
| 59 | 5:08.35 | Drew PaccioneWest Islip | West Islip '19 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2017 |
| 60 | 5:08.39 | Daniel MullanSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '21 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2018 |
| 61 | 5:08.62 | Ric Jehrard AguilarSt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '22 | Saint Anthony's Developmental Meet 2 | 2019 |
| 62 | 5:09.19 | Patrick DiMariaCommack | Commack '12 | St Joseph's College Indoor Invitational | 2018 |
| 63 | 5:10.08 | Nicholas SchiedaSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '17 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2015 |
| 64 | 5:10.34 | Devin LaudenschlagerSt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '16 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2014 |
| 65 | 5:10.55 | Jeremy AndersonBrentwood | Brentwood '17 | St Joseph's College Indoor Invitational | 2018 |
| 66 | 5:10.93 | Daniel BaezSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '17 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2015 |
| 67 | 5:11.63 | Sean McCormickConnetquot | Connetquot '20 | Saint Anthony's Developmental Meet 2 | 2019 |
| 68 | 5:11.68 | Vincent CotroneDeer Park | Deer Park '15 | Saint Anthony's Boys Developmental Meet | 2013 |
| 69 | 5:12.36 | Bryan SpinellaSmithtown East | Smithtown East '18 | St. John's University 14th Annual Bill Ward Invitational | 2018 |
| 70 | 5:12.86 | Greg RachmanJohn Glenn | John Glenn '12 | St Joseph's College Indoor Invitational | 2018 |
| 71 | 5:13.42 | William MaddenSt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '17 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2014 |
| 72 | 5:13.64 | Justin O'RourkeSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '15 | Saint Anthony's Boys Developmental Meet | 2013 |
| 73 | 5:15.16 | Jayson PlazaSt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '22 | Saint Anthony's Developmental Meet 2 | 2019 |
| 74 | 5:15.33 | Edward ReillySt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '22 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2018 |
| 75 | 5:16.87 | Christian MehrtensConnetquot | Connetquot '22 | Saint Anthony's Developmental Meet 2 | 2019 |
| 76 | 5:17.18 | Kevin SandersShoreham-Wading River | Shoreham-Wading River '11 | St. John's University Bill Ward Invitational | 2013 |
| 77 | 5:17.25 | William HanleyRocky Point | Rocky Point '15 | Saint Anthony's Boys Developmental Meet | 2013 |
| 78 | 5:18.51 | Shane AcostaPatchogue-Medford | Patchogue-Medford '12 | Molloy College Indoor Invitational | 2015 |
| 79 | 5:18.58 | Louis AquinoSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '16 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2015 |
| 80 | 5:18.95 | Thomas RouletteSt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '18 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2014 |
| 81 | 5:20.60 | Bryan LaconteWest Babylon | West Babylon '14 | Saint Anthony's Boys Developmental Meet | 2013 |
| 82 | 5:20.77 | Sean FitzgeraldSt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '22 | Saint Anthony's Developmental Meet 2 | 2019 |
| 83 | 5:21.82 | Michael BertlesmanSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '15 | Saint Anthony's Boys Developmental Meet | 2013 |
| 84 | 5:21.88 | Nick CirasoleSt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '18 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2014 |
| 85 | 5:22.66 | Benjamin VassalloNorth Babylon | North Babylon '08 | St. John's University Indoor Track Meet | 2010 |
| 86 | 5:23.20 | John MillerSt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '20 | Saint Anthony's Developmental Meet 2 | 2019 |
| 87 | 5:23.21 | Thomas SandovalDeer Park | Deer Park '15 | Saint Anthony's Boys Developmental Meet | 2013 |
| 88 | 5:24.22 | Kevin BudveitSt. John the Baptist | St. John the Baptist '20 | Saint Anthony's Developmental Meet 2 | 2019 |
| 89 | 5:24.57 | Dorian ScourtosWest Islip | West Islip '21 | Saint Anthony's Developmental Meet 2 | 2019 |
| 90 | 5:26.54 | Tyler BesendorferSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '20 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2018 |
| 91 | 5:27.00 | Matthew OttomanelliSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '17 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2015 |
| 92 | 5:27.54 | Steven TownsendRocky Point | Rocky Point '15 | Saint Anthony's Boys Developmental Meet | 2013 |
| 93 | 5:29.72 | Ryan BrownDeer Park | Deer Park '17 | Saint Anthony's Boys Developmental Meet | 2013 |
| 94 | 5:30.94 | Aidan SchretzmayerSt. Anthony's | St. Anthony's '17 | Saint Anthony's Boys - Girls Developmental | 2015 |
| 95 | 5:45.87 | Adam AhmedDeer Park | Deer Park '15 | Saint Anthony's Boys Developmental Meet | 2013 |
| 96 | 6:05.93 | Brian RamsarranCentral Islip | Central Islip '16 | St Joeph College Men | |
| 97 | 6:56.60 | Sameer ChowdhuryWest Babylon | West Babylon '12 | St. John's University Bill Ward Invitational | 2016 |
